Canadian Opera Firm: Gounod’s Roméo et Juliette. Amy Lane, director; COC Orchestra and Refrain, Yves Abel, conductor. Forged: Stephen Costello, Roméo; Kseniia Proshina, Juliette; Alex Hetherington, Stéphano; Gordon Bintner, Mercutio; Owen McCausland, Tybalt. October 8, 2025, 4 Seasons Centre, Toronto. Continues to October 18; tickets right here.
‘The sunshine-minded Frenchman (…) who seems to be at each dramatic work at the beginning from the perspective of its outward results.’
Tchaikovsky was excoriating Ambroise Thomas and his Hamlet opera. However, he would possibly as properly have been describing Gounod’s Roméo et Juliette. which was composed a yr or two earlier.
It could be good to say that historical past has proved Tchaikovsky fallacious — he might be an illiberal critic. However in reality, each operas share the identical staff of librettists — Jules Barbier and Michel Carré — and every is a stripped-down hackwork of a Shakespearean masterpiece.
As for the music, each are so over-sweetened they need to include a well being warning. Lastly, to Gounod’s beneficiant sprinkling, Amy Lane’s staging, first introduced in Malmö, provides an entire additional layer of baked meringue. Cliché after cliché in libretto, music, and staging makes this an enervating three-hour sugar fest.
The Manufacturing
In her notes, Lane, who was additionally in control of Gounod’s a lot superior Faust at COC final yr, explains her idea, whereby occasions are transported to New York of the Eighties.
The Montagues are Italian immigrants making an attempt to settle, and the explanation for his or her feud with the Capulets is cash. Even had it labored, the concept would in all probability have added little perception or redemption. However in follow, little of it got here throughout; some token early skyscrapers, maybe overlooking Central Park, and a mafioso swimsuit for Juliette’s father had been kind of it.
The opening act is about as a cacophonic burlesque social gathering. The refrain are in colourfully lavish costumes (designed by Emma Ryott), with clown-cum-harlequin dancers stage entrance. As in Lane’s Faust staging, there isn’t a robust raison d’être for the dancers’ presence; neither is their choreography significantly fascinating.
At occasions it seems like she is making an attempt to distract us from the admittedly not terribly distinguished music — why precisely Rely Capulet (a resonant if not fairly vocally even Mark Stone) ought to strip to a corset and fishnets remained a thriller, although it does elevate some faint titters.
Performances
Kseniia Proshina’s Juliette actually regarded the half, which is under no circumstances all the time the case with operatic Juliettes. Vocally she is sweet-toned and delicate, however with out the radiance that aficionados would possibly count on from the one memorable tune of the opera, her Act 1 ‘Je veux vivre’.
Nor was she completely helped by the awkward staging — positioned at occasions on an elevated platform and backed by dancers making foolish actions, even after her pretend dying. Stephen Costello’s Romeo, a great much less believable as a young person, had the required energy and stamina for Gounod’s high-tessitura writing, however scored much less extremely for tenderness.
By the third act, Lane appeared to have run out of concepts. However, she nonetheless managed to place Friar Laurence — a priest — in a laboratory coat, and to position a cupboard of potions centre-stage within the scene of the lovers’ secret wedding ceremony.
In the meantime, a lot of the appearing was as flat because the phrases had been trite, at occasions even surpassing them for blandness. Romeo’s description of morning lights had no impact on the complete moon that dominated every scene. A starrier forged, some fierier chemistry, and stronger route would possibly conceivably have saved the day.
However, the transient second of pseudo-hallucination following Juliette’s imbibing was too complicated to make a lot impression.
Proshina and Costello had been backed by a dependable supporting forged: Owen MacCausland’s Tybalt specifically impressed along with his free-flowing tenor. Gordon Bintner’s Mercutio was larger-than-life, and Alex Halliday’s Duke introduced a contact of superior vocal class, regardless of his function being so misplaced in Lane’s staging that she discovered no higher answer than having him stabbed to dying.
The orchestra beneath the baton of Yves Abel took some time to settle on the efficiency I attended however supplied plush colors and harmonies thereafter.
Last Ideas
Roméo et Juliette had been absent from the Canadian Stage for over 30 years. I doubt whether or not many can be unhappy if it takes one other 30 to return, until COC can up its sport and convey us a first-class manufacturing.
Are you trying to promote an occasion? Have a information tip? Have to know the very best occasions occurring this weekend? Ship us a observe.
#LUDWIGVAN
Get the every day arts information straight to your inbox.
Join the Ludwig Van Toronto e-Blast! — native classical music and opera information straight to your inbox HERE.
Michelle Assay is a Marie Curie/UKRI World Fellow on the Universities of Toronto and King’s School London engaged on Ladies and Western Artwork Music in Iran (Womusiran.com). She holds a PhD from the Sorbonne and College of Sheffield and has been a Leverhulme Fellow on the College of Huddersfield. She is the creator of award-winning articles on Russian and Soviet music and on Shakespeare and music, and commonly seems in concert events as a pianist. She is a daily broadcaster for the BBC and contributor to Gramophone, Worldwide Piano, and Bachtrack, together with Ludwig Van.
